Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Natalia Extin

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

State Farm® Insurance Agent Natalia Extin

221 N Main St
Suite A
Winchester, IN 47394-9219

2 blocks north of The Square

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Natalia Extin

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
Call us 24 hours a day!


221 N Main St
Suite A
Winchester, IN 47394-9219



Welcome to our corner of the web! I'm Natalia Extin, a dedicated second-generation State Farm Agent with a passion for helping individuals and families. At Natalia Extin, State Farm Insurance , we are the insurance agency for you. Serving the residents of Winchester, Indiana, and customers throughout Ohio, and Indiana. We understand the unique insurance needs of our neighbors in Indiana and Ohio, making us your go-to source for dependable insurance coverage.

I take pride in following in my family's footsteps and continuing the tradition of providing top-notch insurance services to our customers. With my family's tradition and the extensive experience of over 50 years of our staff, we understand the unique needs of our customers.

As your State Farm agent, my team and I are committed to delivering personalized service, tailored options with a friendly family touch. We strive to build lasting relationships with our customers and emphasize financial security as a priority.

  • Auto Insurance: Whether you're a seasoned driver or a new one, we can help you find the coverage to protect you and your vehicle.

  • Fire Insurance: Your home is your sanctuary, and we'll work with you to safeguard it against unexpected events, providing comprehensive home insurance options.

  • Renters Insurance: Don't underestimate the importance of renters insurance. By assisting you in choosing the fight policy to protect your personal belongings and provide liability coverage.

  • Life Insurance: Planning for the future is essential. Let's discuss life insurance options to ensure your loved ones are financially secure in the event of the unexpected.

Ready to discuss your insurance needs? Reach out to us today for a personalized consultation. We are here to answer your questions provide quotes and assist with claims.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products


Our Mission is to be the leading source for insurance services in Winchester and surrounding areas in Indiana and Ohio by providing great service and options to protect and strengthen our friends, family, neighbors and community. We take our time to complete a personalized comprehensive review of our customer's Insurance needs to create Personal Price Plan. We want to be the first and preferred choice for all of our customer's Insurance and Financial Service needs in Indiana and Ohio. We focus on Auto, Home, Business, and Life Insurance.

We are a full service Agency located in Winchester, Indiana. We extend our range of services to provide auto, homeowners, renters, life and health insurance products to all of Ohio and Indiana.

Tonya Hummel, Office Manager, has been with the agency for over twenty years. She really enjoys assisting customer's car, home, and life needs. She focuses her talents with new customers as well as our current customers.

Mason Extin is our Customer Service Representative. Mason works with assisting customers to navigate claims, process changes to current accounts, and apply payments.

Our staff is available by appointment and walk ins Monday thru Friday 9-5, and after hours by appointment. We also offer the latest technology for our customers with apps for your mobile devices and desktops. Plus 24x7 service for all of our customer service. Also, ask us about our new Virtual Meeting options.

Tonya Hummel State Farm Agent Team Member

Tonya Hummel

Office Manager

Tonya is a lifelong resident of Winchester. While in High School, she started her career as a part time employee in our office. After graduating, she came on board full time and is licensed in both Property & Casualty Insurance and Life & Health Insurance. She has been your service guru for the first 18 years as our Office Manager. Tonya focus on assisting our new customers with their Personal Price Plan. She is excellent at assisting you with your Auto, Home, Renters, Life and Health insurance. Designing and providing options for your situation.

Mason Extin State Farm Agent Team Member

Mason Extin

Customer Service Representative

Mason graduated from Hamilton Southeastern High School in 2015. Mason has been a team member since 2016. He is licensed in Indiana and Ohio to help you with Homeowners, Auto and Renters insurance. His focus is to assist customers with claim processing, policy changes, and payment processing.

He is a huge sports fan, Go Hawks, Bulls and Bears. He enjoys spending time with his family and friends.

Stop in and visit our State Farm location in Winchester to meet Mason and the rest of the team. Feel free to call.

Lauren Rhotehamel State Farm Agent Team Member

Lauren Rhotehamel

Account Representative

  • Lauren graduated from Randolph Southern in 2019 and Indiana University in 2022 with a degree in Business Administration. Lauren loves being with friends and family and going to the gym. Most of the time you can find her with dog, Bentley, that likes to take long walks. Lauren is licensed in Indiana and Ohio and loves to make sure customers are accurately covered. Assisting new customers with their Personal Price Plans is her goal. Stop by and meet Lauren.

Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.